Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

GET RID OF JEDI CLASSFollow

#27 Jan 29 2008 at 8:17 AM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
jedi are Star wars after all.

But yeah there is to many openly wandering the streets. I'll be honest i like others pre cu couldn't be bothered with the whole jedi grind thing, it was always something i would get around to eventually, part of me was actually looking forward to the solitude of grinding my jeid in a little house way out in the middle of no where were no one would see me, but i hadn't bee nhere long and i was still enjoying my game blah blah blah...........

Anyway the nge came and all that went bye-bye i was for a long time quite sad and delcared i woukld never have a NGE jedi.............. well till they gave us our second toons then i was like ***** you SOE im gonna be a NGE jadddi just like all the other mad kids hopping around the SP, But that soon got boring, well after about 5 mins to be honest.............i dont understand the fasination with the pointless jumping, but hey if it keeps them happy.

Anyway long story short i got to like it, i find its not so much being a jedi i like, as much as its like my old masterdoc/Master Swords template which is where i was always the most happiest..........without having to worry about healing anyone else lol. So eventually i even respeced my main to be a respec jeaadi. Sell out i know! sometime i even make my self sick. just tell me you will still respect me in the morning.

But i do think there is to many jedi visably walking the streets. People that know me will tell you, my jedi is rarely seen holding a saber, only ever wears robes when she heading in to a fight. and when attacked by npc in town usually shoots them or uses an normal sword. Infact there is usually very little sign that she is a jedi at all, and that has been my chosen play style.

I would infact like to see a new visablity system in place, I wanna see visablity back not to curb the no. of jedi, after all thats a choise for all of us, but to give it some depth and maybe even take away a few of the visable jedi and put us back in to some sort of hiding. After all this is set between ep 4 and 5, not as mentioned by some one earlier the new jedi order, that is after the death of the emp and vader. order 66 is still in operation the emp still pretty much has control of the emipire and the rebelion is still gathering steam.

But if that was done i would also like to see jedi move away for the robes for protection. Personally i hate the fact that really jedi have 2 or 4 option for their armour. considerably less than that of the rest of the proffesions and thats not even taking in to account colour variation.

This of course is a sticky subject, it seems many feel jedi get to much attention as it is and should not get more, and of course there is various pro and against arguments over it all.

I dont think i wanna see Jedi have inaitte armour. Basically thats the easy answer, but with the idiots we have will lead to an army of pink winged hawtpanted jedi running amock jumping around everywhere like a cockroach infestation.

I think what i would like to see is something where we can RE our cloaks (not robes) in to a jacket or robe of our own choise. This i think would be cool, it would give jedi some individuality and not make us quite so obviously stood out.

I also think for the jedi grinding up as an alternertive to robes should be able to see tailors. tailors who are able to procure parts from an A/S to use in RE'ing the availble looted armoured clothing. This could also be a two pronged thing, one way it comes out for the mere mortals to wear, the other way it comes out for the jedi to wear. This clothing of course will be lower statted than full on armour as it is now which the jedi robes and cloaks already are in the 1st place(discuss?)
#28 Jan 29 2008 at 8:50 AM Rating: Decent
****
5,644 posts
holy crap, id hate to be inside your head, your posts are always so huge, so ill just say about what i actually read before my mind wandered, innate armour, personally, id rather have craftable armour clothes.

it would be a similar thing to innate armour, but it would give crafters something to do that will affect jedi.

plus, then not every jedi will look the same.

my ithorian, i had him ajedi for a bit, and it was nice, the master cloak doesnt show graphically on me, so i was running around in my blue and white camo pants and my racing helm, with no shirt, and it was nice being diffeant while still having viable armour.
#29 Jan 29 2008 at 12:23 PM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
MasterOfWar wrote:
holy crap, id hate to be inside your head, your posts are always so huge, so ill just say about what i actually read before my mind wandered, innate armour, personally, id rather have craftable armour clothes.

it would be a similar thing to innate armour, but it would give crafters something to do that will affect jedi.

plus, then not every jedi will look the same.

my ithorian, i had him ajedi for a bit, and it was nice, the master cloak doesnt show graphically on me, so i was running around in my blue and white camo pants and my racing helm, with no shirt, and it was nice being diffeant while still having viable armour.


If only you had lasted out another paragraph or so lol

Thats what i said lol.

And sorry i cant help it, i try to stay breif but it just goes on and on and on! theink how the people around me feel lol.

#30 Jan 29 2008 at 12:28 PM Rating: Decent
****
5,644 posts
i know what thats like i ramble alot aswell
#31 Jan 30 2008 at 7:14 AM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
its the voices they make me do it
#32 Feb 06 2008 at 12:24 AM Rating: Decent
Tell that to the people who unlocked in pre you son of a Beeeeeeeep! Yeah thats right I said it.

Back then it took tooth, toenail, blood and tears to grind xp...Its waaaaaay easier now!
#33 Feb 06 2008 at 3:55 AM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
Gramsmama wrote:
Tell that to the people who unlocked in pre you son of a Beeeeeeeep! Yeah thats right I said it.

Back then it took tooth, toenail, blood and tears to grind xp...Its waaaaaay easier now!


And i will say to you what i would say to the anyone else that has not let go yet. get over it move on its been 2 years now

Where were you when the fhit hit the san and we were pushing for things to be changed?

Where wer eyou when the server population hit the floor?

Oh yeah it did didn't it. Now don't make me make you look silly by pointing out it was just long winded not difficult. Done right you incured no visiblity, you just headed out to the wilderness and grinded out your xp.

No visiblity = no BH's No BH's = no Xp loss.

Yeah it took months, but they were frakking hard once you got them to full template, so it was obviously worth it.

No if you want my sympathy talk about the people that didn't quite make it to unlocking pre CU. all the work they put in to be so close to unlocking, yet got nothing. where as even if you just unlocked the day before you got your elder title, a master jedi with no grinding and a elder cloak ( back when it actually made a diffrence)

And yeah its way easier now, the whole game is way easier, and non the better for it.

But i have come to accept there is no place for an ALPHA class in a MMO. But you cant have a SW game without jedi now can you.

And for your imformation im no ones son...........I AM THAT BEEEEEP! YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT

:P



Edited, Feb 6th 2008 8:04am by EmjayR
#34 Feb 06 2008 at 3:48 PM Rating: Decent
**
631 posts
If I thought that Emjay for one second and been the least little offened...that this would be a very colorful post...at this point I'm still considering smoking you like a $5 doobie....but I won't. Listen tool....why don't you take your ball and go home....we don't wanna play with you anymore. Go find you little friends and leave the adults alone while we talk about adult things ok.....Thanks......Have a day :|
____________________________
Be Well...Shoot First...Die Last

Order Exists Only To Create Chaos...In Chaos Is Where I Dwell
(Quote Of The Black Rose)
#35 Feb 06 2008 at 5:10 PM Rating: Decent
This topic was originally posted last october yet people to this day are still replying. The Jedi aren't going anywhere. Move on already.
#36 Feb 06 2008 at 10:31 PM Rating: Decent
**
601 posts
Quote:
This topic was originally posted last october yet people to this day are still replying. The Jedi aren't going anywhere. Move on already.


I don't want to move on. I like hearing about the voices in Emjay's head, It makes the voices in my head feel like they have company!!

Agrilok
#37 Feb 07 2008 at 2:55 AM Rating: Decent
Well, I was pre NGE player, like many here. Lets not forget all the good stuff that led to Jedi hunting in that era, for example like having a whole guild dedicated to just that was just pure fun with all the resources it took to get there, and its availabilty in the world...

Now that everyone gets their own little bubble of pleasure at the NGE character creation, just like in WoW, there's no need to make use of the environment in the same way, and other people for that matter. People dont go out discovering what they want out from the world's dynamics since they know that already before even playing! Hence the real experience of the game turns to goo.

Before, someone with the lowest set of skills and plenty of directions to choose from could always be of help to anybody, no matter what he did and no matter when. If he decided he was going to begin spending his time fishing for the guild's Chef, he could. If he decided he had enough of it and had aquired good surveying skills in the meantime, well he could just go work for the guild's crafter. If he had gathered enough fighting skills whilst hunting for pelts to start thinking about pvp, he could! Once he'd had his fun mastering a few professions and start thinking about becoming Jedi, but not until then, he could. He wouldn't be forced to keep dwelling on the idea either! He could literally try anything that world had to offer. A start by waving his little fishing stick around was enough to matter right away, and if he couldn't be bothered with reaching jedi anymore, well there was plenty out there to get busy and have fun with. And its not like being jedi was garenteed safety...

Now, hunting for resources has become a loathed activity since all of its need has been directed towards the efficiency of becoming THE pimp pvp badass of all.
Which in my opinion, kills all gameplay dynamics this game once stood for which didn't invlove forcing people in boxes.

What's the most important thing about mmo's? Being nothing more but your sh*tty little Uber Avatar or actually having fun with people?

Long live the age of Myths and Heroes!

So in conclusion:
This game now smells like McDonalds, with clients looking real busy burping their Big Macs...

But I mean I havent played for a year and a half so, perhaps these dynamics have come back, I dont know and I cannot be ***** to pay a month. So if anyone's willing to rape anything I've said, go ahead and tell, whats it really like now?

Edited, Feb 7th 2008 6:33am by Erkinn
#38 Feb 07 2008 at 1:48 PM Rating: Decent
**
631 posts
Since I have started.....little over a year ago... I have been crafting for the most part...I have combat classes...but rarely play them....my guild like my shipwright to the point where I am acting Leader of the Fist. I PVE like a crazy fool...and alot of others do as well. I won't deny that there are those who walk around with their electronic erection for PVP...but I haven't found it really nessisary to PVP...my guild does both and if someone wants to PVP me in space...bring it don't sing it....but land based PVP...I have 4 kills...I am SHIPWRIGHT here me roar. LOL....does that help you Erkinn.
____________________________
Be Well...Shoot First...Die Last

Order Exists Only To Create Chaos...In Chaos Is Where I Dwell
(Quote Of The Black Rose)
#39 Feb 11 2008 at 10:28 AM Rating: Decent
na leave em. more lambs for the slaughter

seeing alot of jedi doesn't bother me as i know 2/3s of them don't know their profesion very well and go down in pvp. besides it shouldn't bother you so much how ppl play their game- every MMO has some class that the masses gravitate to.. If they FR its a morale victory anyway, but I find Jedi aren't as invulnerable as they seem.

If you don't PvP I don't see what the issue is anyway. Just look at it as its easier for you to be unique when most ppl play but geez taking Jedi out from game is just retarded do you really want 3/4s of the current population to quit? ppl who love jedi aren't going to stick around if there forced to play something they dont like.. This arguements dead horse anyway.
#40 Feb 11 2008 at 10:34 AM Rating: Decent
[quote=riffasiempre]Order 66 anybody?

yes every day
#41 Feb 11 2008 at 1:58 PM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
Erkinn wrote:
Well, I was pre NGE player, like many here. Lets not forget all the good stuff that led to Jedi hunting in that era, for example like having a whole guild dedicated to just that was just pure fun with all the resources it took to get there, and its availabilty in the world...
.............................................................................
So in conclusion:
This game now smells like McDonalds, with clients looking real busy burping their Big Macs...

But I mean I havent played for a year and a half so, perhaps these dynamics have come back, I dont know and I cannot be ***** to pay a month. So if anyone's willing to rape anything I've said, go ahead and tell, whats it really like now?

Edited, Feb 7th 2008 6:33am by Erkinn


Well Said!
#42 Feb 11 2008 at 2:01 PM Rating: Excellent
**
946 posts
Jerok wrote:
na leave em. more lambs for the slaughter

seeing alot of jedi doesn't bother me as i know 2/3s of them don't know their profesion very well and go down in pvp. besides it shouldn't bother you so much how ppl play their game- every MMO has some class that the masses gravitate to.. If they FR its a morale victory anyway, but I find Jedi aren't as invulnerable as they seem.

If you don't PvP I don't see what the issue is anyway. Just look at it as its easier for you to be unique when most ppl play but geez taking Jedi out from game is just retarded do you really want 3/4s of the current population to quit? ppl who love jedi aren't going to stick around if there forced to play something they dont like.. This arguements dead horse anyway.


Yeah its a dead horse, but we need a little fun and a little spice to discuss every once in a while don't we, besides people like to drag this one up from the depths every once in a while and i need an outlet for the voices in my head!
#43 Feb 11 2008 at 10:04 PM Rating: Good
****
5,644 posts
heres the thing about jedi that the people who dont like jedi/want jedi to be an unlockable alpha class dont get, this game will die without jedi.

if you make jedi an unlockable alpha class again, there will be not as many jedi for maybe, 1, 2 months, then everybody will be jedi again, only this time there will be more, and they will be stronger than everyone else.
#44 Feb 12 2008 at 2:01 PM Rating: Decent
38 posts
For your information, when the game started initially, there were no Jedi because of the timeline conflict. People complained and said what is the point of there being a star wars galaxy with no Jedi. So Jedi were added into the game albeit it was hard to get. Now, there are a lot of things that do not fit in with the timeline but SO WHAT! The game has such a rich encyclopedia of elements that happened in different times and spaces but in SWG they all come together in one mish-mash. Is it canon? The game tried to remain in canon but it was too narrow a timeline for an MMORPG.

No one is FORCING anyone to be a Jedi and there are a lot of them but that is one of the most popular characters in the Star Wars Universe whether Jedi, Sith or force-wielder. It's popularity that makes the character. Who wants to be a regular pistol wielding human when you can use the force. GET OVER IT already!
#45 Feb 13 2008 at 8:41 AM Rating: Good
JanesAnsible wrote:
Who wants to be a regular pistol wielding human when you can use the force. GET OVER IT already!


hokey religions...
#46 Feb 13 2008 at 1:55 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,856 posts
JanesAnsible wrote:
For your information, when the game started initially, there were no Jedi because of the timeline conflict. People complained and said what is the point of there being a star wars galaxy with no Jedi. So Jedi were added into the game albeit it was hard to get. Now, there are a lot of things that do not fit in with the timeline but SO WHAT! The game has such a rich encyclopedia of elements that happened in different times and spaces but in SWG they all come together in one mish-mash. Is it canon? The game tried to remain in canon but it was too narrow a timeline for an MMORPG.

No one is FORCING anyone to be a Jedi and there are a lot of them but that is one of the most popular characters in the Star Wars Universe whether Jedi, Sith or force-wielder. It's popularity that makes the character. Who wants to be a regular pistol wielding human when you can use the force. GET OVER IT already!


Jedi werent in initially because they hadnt finished that portion of the game -yes, it was another game that was released in an unfinished state, but, when you consider the state of the NGE, even to this day, it shouldnt be much of a surprise, and the method to unlock jedi was initialy a secret. then the holocron business came about, and everyone was given a holocron to tell them their first class to master, the reason why the old style jedi were replaced with the new style, was because of the complaints about jedi being overpowered, and, although some found the jedi grind just too hard. the timeline itself has not changed since the games inception. as for sticking to canon, it was the jedi whiners that caused them to drop it, too many people complaining because whenever they drew a glowbat the stormies would attack them, or bounty hunters kill them etc etc. so now we have weak jedi, that are really just a glorified brawler class, and less content in the game because there is no longer any visibility, and bounty hunters are relegated to meaningless missions. As far as it goes, Jedi are pretty much as developed as they need to be, its the others now that need to be worked on more, bounty hunters, should be just that, and smugglers, ideally.. should be able to smuggle and commando's .. just blow things up, get that mixture right and im sure there would be a lot fewer complaints. however, i do have one idea for jedi, and that is the expertise sets, light and dark path jedi, should only be able to choose one or the other, and that once chosen, it activates a factional tef with their opposites, after all, wasnt it standing orders for the jedi to eliminate their darker brethren?
#47 Feb 15 2008 at 11:11 PM Rating: Decent
as of tonight i'm officially sick of em. I've tried to keep an open mind towards them but they stand around acting like their **** don't stink telling one another how "good" of a jedi they are.. all of em dressed like they do assuming they lord over all the other profs. Assuming non jedi want to be like them. Saying things like "its because i'm fast!" when they're agi of 850 blocks all your hits. Fast? No.. Like as if I don't know that block is a passive firing roll, not something you react to.. Do you really want to wear the stupid *** robe and be like every other tom **** and harry? yea more power to ya.
#48 Feb 16 2008 at 4:51 AM Rating: Decent
I agree. I still think Jedi's should be part of the game, but it should go back to being something you unlock from any profession. Maybe there could be a secret Jedi training facility that only those who unlock the prof can reach. Right now Jedi's are the majority prof and it's no fun. Only reason I like it is that it makes trader's more valuable by providing commodities for all these wanton plebs. But i don't like the prof set up right now because it doesn't generate the best possible pvp economy. Vendors are too expensive and money is so easy to come bye. Let's face it: People would rather have a light saber and feel "cool" than learn a valuable trade.
#49 Feb 16 2008 at 4:59 AM Rating: Decent
I guess for jedi fans, if it were something very secret and hard to achieve, jedi players would be respected and rare. If someone achieved that level they would want to keep it a secret and not just "give it away." I think it would create much more intereting dynamics to the class. Are there any "old" jedi out there who were pissed when they made the change?
#50 Feb 16 2008 at 5:58 AM Rating: Decent
****
5,644 posts
like i said in my last post, making jedi unlockable will do nothing but make less jedi for a certain amount of time, after which, everyone who wants to be a jedi will have gotten jedi and your back to square one.

not like jedi was hard to get before, merely time consuming, i mean, before the nge, it was pretty much just a 3 month wait with exp grinding to get jedi.
#51 Feb 16 2008 at 10:31 AM Rating: Decent
MasterOfWar wrote:
like i said in my last post, making jedi unlockable will do nothing but make less jedi for a certain amount of time, after which, everyone who wants to be a jedi will have gotten jedi and your back to square one.

not like jedi was hard to get before, merely time consuming, i mean, before the nge, it was pretty much just a 3 month wait with exp grinding to get jedi.


He's exactly right. Making jedi unlockable ruined the game in the first place (holocron and 32 grinds) I only heard about how cool the game was but I came the week the first jedi unlocked and as a new player it just not what you wanted to see- the community so self asorbed in trying to unlock jedi or buy holocrons.

No one had time for anything else. No one wanted anything to do with any new players because this took time out of their precious trek to jedi. "Oh but the cantinas were so packed preNGE!" yea with a bunch of AFK hologrinders.

We saw in the CU when Jedi got even easier to unlock the same thing but on a more massive scale. Suddenly Jedi became even closer of a dream to these ppl. They suffered no threat of being hunted on places like Kashhyk and just AFKed the village to their hearts content.

It was just jedi jedi jedi jedi just exactly like it is now, except the jedi were more self assorbed back than they are now. There was a tiny minority of players who detested jedi back then and these players were considered "invalids" by the Jedi because according to the jedi mentality- "these players are fat and too lazy to grind jedi like uszors." they had it totally backwards.

These players simply didnt desire some carbon copy win template and were generally bullied and berated by Jedi with all their unchecked dueling at any start port you travelled to. They actually considered themselves lords over the non jedi population, assuming these players were to stupid to read about the complete AFK guides to Jedi on the forums. Really it was the small group of non jedi population that saw through all their *********
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 133 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (133)