HQ staves is one of the big money makers in Woodworking. I can understand where the crafter is coming from. Not only does he lose a possible sale to you by HQing your item but it is entirely possible that by doing so people will drive up the prices on ingredients hoping to piggy-back on the crafters skill causing him to lose even more profit.
I recently read a thread where someone was complaining about a 103 crafter wanting to charge him if the synth was HQ'd. The guy thought this was idiocy because he was bringing all the ingredients for the synth and the crafter had no risk in the synth.
In this case the elemental bead cannot be crafted by anyone except a high level goldsmith which probably means the item was purchased off the auction house. Who buys elemental beads? High level goldsmiths and high level woodworkers are the only ones that can even use them in a synth. Goldsmithers have no need to buy them as they can buy the ore and synth themselves, saving up to 100k at a time. This leads me to believe that woodworkers are the only ones that would buy the elemental beads from the AH. By doing so you are directly competing with the person you are having synth your staff.
To look at it another way:
Elemental staves are a level 75 synth. Percentages of HQ follow this pattern I believe:
10% HQ at 11 over
25% HQ at 31 over
50% HQ at 51 over
As this is a 75 synth in order to hit 25% HQ rate you need to be a 106 woodworker. 100 + 2 gear + 1 furnishing + 3 advanced support = 106. Woot it's possible!
This says nothing for knowing what moon and day to craft one. Now do yourself a favor and look at what it takes to go from 99-100 in woodworking. Granted that is probably the hardest level in the craft as you throw quite a bit of money down the toilet but after doing so I would say they deserve to have a little something for it.
Ragnarzero wrote:
I can understand them wanting to make a profit. but i'm a crafter as well. If somone asks me to make soemthing i jsut craft it and on i go.
I'm also curious as to what level and craft you are. Most people that I've seen say similar things have 1-2 crafts under level 30 and many serious crafters have most if not all of their sub crafts capped at 60.