Raylo wrote:
Archmage Callinon wrote:
One of the main attractions of an expansion is new jobs (classes, professions, souls, w/e) and this removes that as a selling point for new players.
If you're a new player, they're all new jobs to you.
We already know that all jobs are not created equal when it comes to new player appeal.
Objectively, how exciting is scholar compared with ninja? If you answered at all you're wrong, because there's no objective answer to that question.
A brand new player who previously didn't think FFXIV had anything interesting to offer them sees the Heavensward features and says "Oh hey, Dark Knight looks awesome, and I do likes me some ridiculous swords." That guy was previously uninterested in the game for whatever reason, but now wants to try out this new skyscraper-sword wielding class.
Oops. That guy discovers only later that he has to pick one of the jobs he couldn't possibly care less about, take that to 50, do 6 patches worth of story content, and grind to i90 at least before he's able to pick up a great sword and do the thing he wanted to do in the first place.
Know what that guy does? Because it isn't any of those things in that last sentence. He leaves, feeling cheated, and he's right to feel that way.