Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

I think I'm overheating.Follow

#1 Jun 13 2005 at 11:04 AM Rating: Excellent
I recently upgraded to a X800XL to max out my fps on FFXI, but what I've noticed is that I'm crashing A LOT.

I can play an hour or two, then either my computer will lock up, or the moniter will turn off, then back on with a VPU Recovery Error. Originally I thought this was due to the Paging File glitch, but after fixing that, it still does it.

I formatted the computer before installing it, so it's definately not an older drivers issue. I think it may have to do with either over-heating, or the fact that my motherboard is nVidia nForce2 chipset based and is throwing a **** fit. For the time being I've been sticking my box fan up to the side of the computer with the panel off, but that only works for so long. Any suggestions?
#2 Jun 13 2005 at 1:42 PM Rating: Excellent
***
3,771 posts
Have you updated DirectX and done all the Windows updates?
Removed/disabled old video card and any onboard video?
Checked for IRQ conflicts?

Also, has the problem gone away since taking the panel off, and doesn't the VPU recovery utility give an error message or write a log?
#3 Jun 13 2005 at 2:43 PM Rating: Excellent
highRfrequenC wrote:
Have you updated DirectX and done all the Windows updates?
Removed/disabled old video card and any onboard video?
Checked for IRQ conflicts?

Also, has the problem gone away since taking the panel off, and doesn't the VPU recovery utility give an error message or write a log?


1)Windows is fully updated, all drivers are up to date as far as I'm aware of.

2)The computer was formated before installing the video card to prevent older drivers from interfering.

3)Not that computer savvy, as such, I have no idea to check for this.

4) Since taking the panel off, I can go a little longer without crashing the computer. I've noticed that after letting the computer sit for a few hours and turning it on, there are no graphical errors with FFXI. However, about 30min after running, some graphics are distorted and it looks awful. I'll have to take a pic to show you what I mean. Also, the VPU doesn't do anything but say I had an error (and asks if I want to send in a report), much like when a program crashes on windows.
#4 Jun 13 2005 at 3:26 PM Rating: Excellent
**
503 posts
It is definitely overheating. Also, how many Watts is your power supply?

If you know someone who is very good with modding and working with computers, get them to set up watercooling for your box.

If you can't, one thing you can do, is get two large fans...each around 2 feet high and have them blow into the computer from opposite sides with the side panels open.

Or, if you have an air conditioner running nearby, take some large tubing and put one end onto a vent and the other onto an intake fan hole/grill. Duct tape it if you have to. By doing this, it will bring COLD air into the computer all the time thus lowering the average temperature of the box. It is pretty easy to do, and if my parents would let me, that is how I would cool my computer. 2 fans in the back and one in the center which is intake and is connected via pipe to the air conditioner.

Another thing I highly recommend you to do, is to sleeve all of your wires in your computer. Tape them to the sides of the case so there is room for air to flow and so that it is controlled. Group all unused wires, such as those from the power supply and put them all in some bay or tape them to the top of the case. By having wiring out of the way, the air flow is unobstructed and therefore more efficient.

A rather innovative thing you can do is take one of the bottom case expansion panels and open it. Take the little metal plate and drill two holes in it. Attach a stardard 80mm case fan on to the side that goes into your computer and position it such that it will blow into your video card. Hook it up and hope it cools it down a bit. This actually works, and there are even some fans like these sold for $5-10, but why buy one for so much when making it yourself is so much more valuable to computer modding experience and a lot cheaper via do-it-yourself ($0.50 is the fan approximately). It doesn't have to be a Thermaltake or whatever brand fan to do this job. It will just GUARANTEE that air will circulate around your graphics card.

A final thing you can do isn't that innovative, but it works for me. Take some of that colder-than-ice stuff you normally put in your freezer or cooler and put it on top of your computer or onto or next to the intake fan(s). I run a 9800Pro and my motherboard temps are around 38-40 Celsius normally depending on what I am doing. When I put this stuff on the case or near the intake fans, it decreases by 2-3 Celsius pretty quickly. One thing I would suggest though is getting some old newspapers and putting the stuff on them as opposed to straight on the case. Water and electrical supplies don't go well hand-in-hand, which is why I suggest you have a pro do your watercooling instalation if you are going to take that path.

Anyway, good luck in your cooling attempts. Post back on your attempts/failures/successes. I still haven't had a watercooling system for example, nor managed to put the tubing from air conditioner to computer due to other people living in the same place as I do. Would be nice to know the outcomes.

Edit: As usual I mention that there is one awesome program you should take advantage for monitoring your system specs and temperatures: Everest. It is really nice and good if you are having trouble with stuff and want to export all the info about your computer to paste on a forum or other.

Edit: Edit: Here is a page courtesy of Tigerdirect where you can buy expansion slot fans: Click me! They cost ~$5-20. Of course, as aforementioned, it is so much more valuable to do it yourself. It is cheap, efficient, and has some experience value to it, especially since you aren't computer savvy.

Edited, Mon Jun 13 16:30:25 2005 by Bagira

Edited, Mon Jun 13 16:43:02 2005 by Bagira
#5 Jun 13 2005 at 4:04 PM Rating: Excellent
Once again you give great information Bagira. I built the computer myself, however I don't trust myself with water cooling, so I'd like to keep that out of the picture if at all possible.

I BELIEVE my wattage on my PSU is 500 or 550, but it's been so long since I opened the thing up to update anything major, I honestly can't remember. Either way, there should definately be enough power going through the system to keep it stable.

Had I known upgrading my video card would be this troublesome, I probably would've bit the bullet and bought another system specifically for gaming, and switched that computer over to CAD only.

I'll try out that program when I get home and moniter the computer as best as I can in order to give you an idea of what's going on. Also, I'm no stranger to tigerdirect, as that's where I got the majority of my parts for my computer. Smiley: laugh

Currently though I have an ATI Silencer 5 series aftermarket fan on the way to my house, and I hope that should help lower the temperature at least enough to make it stable on FFXI. What's weird is that ATI would choose to point their exhaust fan into the case rather than outside. I'm also looking into adding one more fan to the top of the case via self-modding. Hopefully I'll have enough power to do that.

As it stands though, I -could- try the A/C trick, but then I'd suffer, and my room gets hot enough as is.
#6 Jun 13 2005 at 4:19 PM Rating: Excellent
**
503 posts
I strongly recommend you to get an expansion fan. Place it on the bottom-most expansion slot and it will be fine. The fan will only eat another maybe 1-3 Watts of energy.

I also find it strange that my PSU (ThermalTake Silent Purepower or the like) has 2 fans and it also points the second one into the intereior of my case, which unfortunately is very close to the CPU HS/fan, despite the fact that my case has holes in it for good ventilation it it would have been really nice if I yould have pointed that fan to the top of the case so exhaust heat can go directly out.

I will also try to find that how-to for the do-it-yourself expansion slot fan.

Edit: Can't find it yet, but here is a nice tidbit on a few fans for high-end cards like yours. That Ati Silencer ranks high according to these guys. Nope, can't find the one I wanted, but in any case, it is easy to picture and just as easy to do.

Edited, Mon Jun 13 17:31:33 2005 by Bagira

Edited, Mon Jun 13 17:32:13 2005 by Bagira

Edited, Mon Jun 13 17:39:22 2005 by Bagira
#7 Jun 13 2005 at 7:38 PM Rating: Excellent
Current Temperature read-outs via Everest:

 
Motherboard:   43ËšC 
CPU:           61ËšC 
GPU:           47ËšC 
GPU Ambient:   39ËšC 
HDD:           27ËšC 


Good? Bad?
#8 Jun 13 2005 at 8:36 PM Rating: Good
**
503 posts
I will assume that your computer was 'idle' while you saw those in Everest. Idle meaning, you only had a few windows open, no CAD stuff, maybe FFXI. FFXI does not waste nearly as many resources as older games and programs not made for P4 systems *cough* Mordor *cough*.

The CPU temp is rather hot. One problem you may run into with that one is CPU throttling, which you should have noticed before if you experience rapid slowdowns when doing stuff. Also, certain motherboards emit a very soft high pitched noise. Most people can't hear it, but I can. If you run a P4, this is a really bad temperature. If you run an AMD, it should not be getting anywhere near this hot.

Motherboard temperature is also bad. My motherboard recommends 38 C, but I go over to 40ish anyway. It is just so much harder to cool components effectively with a hot motherboard/in-case temperature. For example, say one person's temps are 30 C and another's are 40C. The one who has the 30 C motherboard temperature will find his CPU and GPU temps much lower because the equilibrium teperature of the case alltogether will be lower. Which is also why intel motherboards in general do not recommend you go over 40 C.

I can't say anything about the GPU temp though because only the X300+ cards can monitor GPU temps.

Do the air conditioner thing and get the expansion slot fan specially for the graphics card air flow. Check the GPU temps an hour or so after keeping the computer on or hour after FFXI playage. If there is a significant difference from when you first turn the computer on wait for 3 minutes and then check temps and the after an hour check, then that is bad. Pray that the Silencer will alleviate that part.

Report back with stuffage as usual, and post the summary please. Just wondering what specs you have other than the card.

Edit: In the rare case you may have an IRQ conflict, you can check in Everest under Devices -> Device Resources at the top.

Edited, Mon Jun 13 21:47:12 2005 by Bagira
#9 Jun 13 2005 at 10:44 PM Rating: Good
***
3,653 posts
Quote:
Motherboard: 43ËšC
CPU: 61ËšC
GPU: 47ËšC
GPU Ambient: 39ËšC
HDD: 27ËšC


61 Degrees C at Idle is very hot for your AMD system there. It could even be your CPU over heating. As suggested case fans are a very good idea if you haven't got your maximum number installed already.

As for keeping the CPU a bit cooler you may want to look at pulling out the CPU, giving it a good clean with Acetone or other cleaning fluids and either re-seating it with a clean heatsink and new thermal paste or a new heatsink and fan combo.

I'd lean towards the latter as you can get some very good quiet heatsink and fan combos (thermaltake) which are very cheap. Those crappy AMD heatsinks tend to have a limited lifespan.

#10 Jun 13 2005 at 10:58 PM Rating: Good
****
7,861 posts
Blowfin wrote:
61 Degrees C at Idle is very hot for your AMD system there. It could even be your CPU over heating.

Pretty sure he's running a Prescott core, but 61 is still too high. I used that Everest program, but the only temperature I got a readout for was my HD. Smiley: confused
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#11 Jun 13 2005 at 11:19 PM Rating: Good
**
503 posts
No. If he is running an LGA775 socket T chip, then it is relatively normal. But if it is socket 478 and without HT, then that is very hot. Hell...when I got my computer with the LGA775, it at first ran around 65 C , but it cooled down later to 50ish.

From what I gather, he has only changed the video card lately, and he has changed it from a 5700LE. With his readings, I may be convinced that it could have been the CPU/motherboard temps that caused the old card not to work very well, even though any LE for Nvidia or SE Ati card is a piece of **** from all perspectives, especially that of gaming.

Oh, and Kastigir, not all motherboards have the various sensors on them. For example, my P4 1.6 GHz computer with whatever old Intel Winnipeg motherboard doesn't have any sensors at all. Only the hard drive temps are shown. And at 27 C, the hard drive is pretty cool compared to rest of the case. Poor circulation?

#12 Jun 13 2005 at 11:56 PM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Bagira wrote:
Oh, and Kastigir, not all motherboards have the various sensors on them. For example, my P4 1.6 GHz computer with whatever old Intel Winnipeg motherboard doesn't have any sensors at all. Only the hard drive temps are shown. And at 27 C, the hard drive is pretty cool compared to rest of the case.

I can understand that, but this is a less than a year old Dell. Is 49 C too hot for my HDD?

Edited, Tue Jun 14 00:58:24 2005 by Kastigir
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#13 Jun 14 2005 at 12:02 AM Rating: Good
***
3,653 posts
Guys? The OP?

Quote:
the fact that my motherboard is nVidia nForce2 chipset based


Deinitely not running Intel. This chip is running too hot at 61c at idle. 40-50 is normal.

Edited, Tue Jun 14 01:33:51 2005 by blowfin
#14 Jun 14 2005 at 12:18 AM Rating: Good
**
503 posts
I've never dealt with the nForce chipset and others. I haven't dealt with anything slightly gamer-oriented at all before like 2 months ago.

I don't see wy you can't run an ATI card on an nVidia board. The drivers from the old card are wiped clean. You don't get a VPU recover thingie unless it overheats and such. Ever used AtiTool to overclock your ATI card and get a VPU recover error? There we go, it overheated.

And, yes, Kastigir, 49 C for a hard drive is very hot. However, I rarely mind, especially since my hard drives have been subjected to as brutal condtions and not one out of over 15 has failed in the last 8 years. Call me lucky.

Edit: Plus, I am waiting until the OP posts back some results of his endeavors.

Edited, Tue Jun 14 01:20:41 2005 by Bagira
#15 Jun 14 2005 at 12:32 AM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Bagira wrote:
And, yes, Kastigir, 49 C for a hard drive is very hot.

Ok, I've already had one HD failure, I really don't want another. What can I do to cool it?
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#16 Jun 14 2005 at 12:38 AM Rating: Good
***
3,653 posts
So much for the OP lol.

Try to make sure they're not in adjacent bays as this builds up heat. If you only have one drive in there then heat *shouldn't* be a problem.

Ventilation is your friend, a front case fan usually gets air flowing over the hard drives and will in general make the whole system cooler. Make sure air sucks in at the front and out at the back of the case if you're going to do it.



Edited, Tue Jun 14 01:42:57 2005 by blowfin
#17 Jun 14 2005 at 12:47 AM Rating: Good
**
503 posts
To Kastigir,

If you want to be really cool, you can go out and mod your case a bit. It isn't very hard, but you'll buy like $20 or so of frames and stuff and make your hard drives removable. I have an old version of these things and it has no fans and stuff on it, but the cover keeps the HD surprisingly cool, despite the fact that when I take out an HD case after a day, it burns to the touch.

If you aren't as leet, you can check out the tigerdirect site with expansion slot case fans and there are two or so that can be inserted into the 5.5" slot and blow air to the hard drive. Or you can get yourself a better case next time. Mine has a single fan at the bottom of the front of my case. it is intake and it is much faster than any of the other fans save maybe the CPU fan. It pulls in cold air like crazy and it is positioned right in front of the hard drive bay. Thus, cold air flows above, below, and around the hard drives cooling them.
#18 Jun 14 2005 at 1:01 AM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Bagira wrote:
If you want to be really cool, you can go out and mod your case a bit. It isn't very hard, but you'll buy like $20 or so of frames and stuff and make your hard drives removable. I have an old version of these things and it has no fans and stuff on it, but the cover keeps the HD surprisingly cool, despite the fact that when I take out an HD case after a day, it burns to the touch.

If you aren't as leet, you can check out the tigerdirect site with expansion slot case fans and there are two or so that can be inserted into the 5.5" slot and blow air to the hard drive. Or you can get yourself a better case next time. Mine has a single fan at the bottom of the front of my case. it is intake and it is much faster than any of the other fans save maybe the CPU fan. It pulls in cold air like crazy and it is positioned right in front of the hard drive bay. Thus, cold air flows above, below, and around the hard drives cooling them.

Ok, this is a Dell system, so the HD is easily removeable. I can open up the case and see about creating some space between the HD and any other drives. I don't think I have any fans at the front of the case, just a couple in the back. 1 is for the CPU heatsink, the other for the rest of the case I guess. I know for a fact that it pulls air in from the front because I have to clean the dust off of it every once in awhile.
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#19 Jun 14 2005 at 1:24 AM Rating: Good
***
3,653 posts
Apart from filling their cases full of proprietary parts Dell make a pretty good case in terms of heat dissipation.

I wouldn't worry too much about more cooling.

Chances are your old hard drive died a natural (albeit premature) death.
#20 Jun 14 2005 at 1:57 AM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Blowfin wrote:
Chances are your old hard drive died a natural (albeit premature) death.

So, you're saying less than a year is a natural, yet premature death? Oh, and I'm still gonna move the drive down if I can. Might as well do everything I can to keep it running because if this piece of sh[red][/red]it breaks again, Dell's gonna get it back in pieces.

Edited, Tue Jun 14 03:01:04 2005 by Kastigir
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#21 Jun 14 2005 at 7:23 AM Rating: Good
***
3,653 posts
Quote:
So, you're saying less than a year is a natural, yet premature death?


Yes, and unlucky. If most hard drives make it past their first year then they're in pretty good shape for a few more usually. It's pretty random stuff, occasionally one company will make a batch of drives with a fault that doesn't get revealed until people's hard drives start dying en-masse well after purchase. If drives aren't handled properly it can damage them also. What brand/model was it out of interest?
#22 Jun 14 2005 at 1:06 PM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Samsung, but I couldn't tell you the model. It was a 160Gig unit.
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#23 Jun 14 2005 at 1:55 PM Rating: Excellent
Ah, I finally figured out the problem, however, I'd still like to take care of my heating issue while we're at it.

What I currently have:

AMD XP 2800+
1024MB RAM (DDR333 I believe)
Maxtor 120GB HDD
MSI-K7N2 Motherboard with nForce2 chipset (quiet you!)
ATI X800XL

That should be the majority of what you need to know. Basically, this was NOT on Idle. This was on running FFXI after about 2 or 3 hours, along with Winamp, Windows Media player, etc, etc. If you can't tell, I multitask a lot on my computer.

The problem actually ended up being Archbell's windower. I've heard of it having problems with ATI cards before, but not quite like this.

Now, as I understand it, 47ËšC isn't too bad for my video card, especially given the limited room I have in my case (I'm so very close to buying a full tower), however, I have a aftermarket fan on the way to take care of that.

As for the CPU, is there anything you'd recommend to bring that down a bit? No water cooling, please. >_>
#24 Jun 14 2005 at 2:19 PM Rating: Excellent
****
7,861 posts
Quote:
As for the CPU, is there anything you'd recommend to bring that down a bit? No water cooling, please.

Larger heatsink, bigger/more fans?
____________________________
People don't like to be meddled with. We tell them what to do, what to think, don't run, don't walk. We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome. ~River Tam

Sedao
#25 Jun 14 2005 at 2:32 PM Rating: Excellent
The fan is already freaking huge.
#26 Jun 14 2005 at 5:22 PM Rating: Excellent
**
503 posts
Sorry to say, but you can't really effectively cool the CPU without either incresing air flow by a LOT or by decreasing the overall temps inside the case, also referred to as the motherboard temp.

FFXI/pol does not take much CPU usage actually. As long as you minimize the processes like winamp and stuff and not do CAD stuff while on ffxi, it still should not heat up that much after 3 hoursish. For me, ffxi takes up ~13% on one of my 'two' CPUs due to HT. It isn't a lot. And after a whole day of it running, the temps are still around 50-55ish for my intel LGA775 chipset, which isn't warm at all. Maybe there is some process that eats CPU usage? On my old computer there was one process called rnaathchk.exe which was the real player autoupdate which at usage, so check the CPU usage at startup or a bit afterwards to make sure nothing is being 'wasted'. Or lower the overall motherboard temperature. Again, if colder air passes over the heatsink, more heat can be transferred to the air flow, thus a lower equilibrium CPU/MB temp.

I am hhappy that you solved the issue with it being the Windower. I hope it is mainly confined to the newer cards because so far, I've had no problems with my 9800Pro as long as I don't overclock it.

Oh, and a larger heatsink/fan won't really work. A fan capable of delivering higher Cfm is good. A heatsink whose main material has a higher specific heat is also good, since it will be able to take a lot more heat and not go up as much temperaturage overall. So materials of heatsink and the Cfmage of a fan are good, but size doesn't really play a large role. I remember reading a review about a HUGE CPU HS/fan for the LGA775 chips. It was basically the size of one of those Brita water filters and the shape of a blimp. It was huge, and it made a lot of noise, but the cooling was still sub-par to that of the stock intel HS/fan.
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 12 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (12)