I didn't read through everything, but I agree about this:
Quote:
I'm really against it because A) alla's general lack of authority on the topic
Seriously. If you invite all of the anime crowd here, you will end up with having to deal with cp. Don't believe me? Send me a pm and we'll talk (admin only). I'm not saying that all, or even most anime fans are 'those kinds of people' but a lot of them are. -points to 4chan ref above- And, you can hang out and say whatever, we didn't see it, but it will be on your servers, and guess who will go to jail. Not me. :)
So, alla, if you decide to do it, you're opening yourself up to a, more manpower to deal with it and b, liability, baby, oh yes. You can smoke that in your pipe.
So, that's my vote; I think you can figure it out.