Divine Divinity ?
I picked this up at Fry's for $30 despite the questionable graphics and insight to gameplay the package (and later manual) showed at first glance. Later I started to realize the manual and installation were very well put together. The character selection interface made me wonder about the graphics quality as well.
Getting into gameplay I found this to be an AWESOME game. As I played I could feel elements of many games I had played recently..EQ, Diablo2, Morrowind, NWN, etc. Its a very well put together game, the graphics in game are beautiful (to say the least), and its a great way to fill time in while the servers are down or when you can't find a group. I've even taken to playing it over EQ until I see enough of its content (there are HOURS and HOURS of it).
Interested to hear what others think of it too tho. Only issue I have had is with crashes...which are totally fixed by downloading the 10MB patch from the support site. I strongly recommend doing that BEFORE you start a game if your trying. I got about 17 hours into it then patched...all the stats (everything except item name) were stripped from everything I had touched in game afterwards :(